Income protection vs critical illness cover: the difference
Last checked: 2 November 2026
Income protection and critical illness cover are two different types of insurance. Income protection pays a regular monthly income, usually a share of earnings, while illness or injury stops someone from working. Critical illness cover pays a single lump sum if the person is diagnosed with one of the serious conditions listed in the policy, whether or not they can still work. One replaces income over time. The other pays one amount, once.
The main differences
| Feature | Income protection | Critical illness cover |
|---|---|---|
| What it pays | A regular monthly income | A one-off lump sum |
| What triggers a payment | Being unable to work because of illness or injury | Diagnosis of a condition listed in the policy |
| Conditions covered | Any illness or injury that stops work, subject to the policy terms | Only the conditions named in the policy |
| Amount | A share of income, typically 50% to 65% | A fixed sum chosen when the policy starts |
| When it pays | After the chosen deferred period | Once the diagnosis meets the policy definition |
| How long it pays | Until a return to work or the end of the benefit period | Once, as a single payment |
| Number of claims | Usually more than one claim over the policy's life | Usually one claim, after which the cover ends |
| Linked to working | Yes | No |
How income protection works
Income protection is a policy that pays a monthly income if illness or injury stops someone working. MoneyHelper says it typically pays between 50% and 65% of income.
- Trigger: the person is unable to work, as defined in the policy. Definitions range from "own occupation" (cannot do their own job) to "any occupation" (cannot do any job).
- Waiting time: payments start after a deferred period, commonly 4, 13 or 26 weeks, or a year.
- Length: payments continue until the person can work again, or until the benefit period or policy term ends.
- Any cause: it can pay for a wide range of conditions, from a back injury to a mental health condition, as long as the person cannot work and the policy terms are met.
The guide Income protection deferred periods explained covers the waiting time in more detail.
How critical illness cover works
Critical illness cover pays a lump sum if the person is diagnosed with a serious condition listed in the policy.
- Trigger: a diagnosis that meets the policy's definition of a listed condition. Common examples are some cancers, heart attack and stroke.
- Not linked to work: the payment does not depend on being off work. A person can receive it and carry on working.
- One payment: the full sum is usually paid once, and the policy then ends. Some policies pay a smaller partial amount for less severe conditions.
- Fixed amount: the sum is chosen when the policy starts, and the money can be used for anything.
Each policy has its own list of conditions and its own definitions. A condition that is not on the list, or that does not meet the definition, is not covered.
The same illness, two different results
The two types of cover can respond very differently to the same event.
- A long back problem that stops work for a year. Income protection can pay a monthly income once the deferred period ends. Critical illness cover would not normally pay, because a back problem is not usually a listed condition.
- A cancer diagnosis, with the person well enough to keep working. Critical illness cover can pay the lump sum if the diagnosis meets the policy definition. Income protection would not pay while the person can still work.
- A heart attack followed by six months off work. Critical illness cover can pay the lump sum. Income protection can also pay a monthly income for the time off work, once the deferred period ends.
In numbers, for someone earning £2,500 a month before tax with an income protection policy paying 50% after a 13-week deferred period, and a critical illness policy with a £50,000 lump sum:
| Event | Income protection | Critical illness cover |
|---|---|---|
| Back problem, off work for a year | About £11,250 (39 weeks, about 9 months × £1,250) | Nothing, if not a listed condition |
| Cancer diagnosis, still working | Nothing while working | £50,000, if the diagnosis meets the definition |
| Heart attack, off work for 6 months | About £3,750 (13 weeks, about 3 months × £1,250) | £50,000, if the diagnosis meets the definition |
These are general illustrations. Whether either policy pays depends on its terms.
What claims data shows
Figures from the Association of British Insurers for 2025 show the difference in what each type of cover pays for:
- Income protection: a record £209 million was paid on individual claims. About a third of claims were for musculoskeletal conditions, such as back and joint problems, the most common reason.
- Critical illness cover: £1.25 billion was paid on individual claims. About two-thirds of claims (65%) were for cancer.
How the two can work together
Income protection and critical illness cover are separate policies, and some people hold both. Because they pay out for different things, they do not overlap in full:
- The lump sum from critical illness cover can be used for one-off costs, such as paying down a mortgage, adapting a home or covering treatment.
- The monthly income from income protection can cover ongoing bills while the person is unable to work.
What income protection does not cover
Income protection provides cover if you can't work due to accident or illness. It does not cover redundancy or unemployment. Each policy also has its own terms and exclusions, which are set out in the policy documents.
Getting a quote through this site
Quotes through this site are for income protection, for people aged 18 to 59 who work at least 16 hours a week, employed or self-employed. After the short form, an income protection broker phones to talk through the options. The broker arranges everything by phone.
Compare income protection plans.
Compare plans